taste of wild vs blue buffalo

A complete comparison: Taste Of Wild vs Blue Buffalo

Let’s take an in-depth comparison between Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo cat foods and find out which is better.

As responsible pet owners, we need to make sure that our cats' nutritional needs are being met.

Of course, our feline pets can only achieve this through their primary source of nutrients – their food.

To ensure that our pets are getting the best quality cat food, we need to be meticulous in choosing a particular brand.

Choosing the best food for your kitty is quite a challenge because there are multitudes of different brands in the market.

However, when it comes to cat food, two brands are leading the way: Taste of the Wild and Blue Buffalo.

There must be reasons why these two leading brands are the preferred products among pet owners.

However, which of these two is better? Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo Wilderness, which is the right cat food for your kitty?

This article will focus on comparing Taste of the Wild vs Blue Buffalo Wilderness.

We're going to highlight the key differences as well as the similarities between these two pet food brands.

Their different features and benefits should help you decide which particular product to choose.

However, it would take more than merely knowing their features in coming up with a wise decision.

We also need to consider other relevant factors such as brand history, ingredient quality, product safety, nutritional value, and flavor. Not to forget the price, of course.

So, let’s start this Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo comparison to help you choose the cat food that is most appropriate for your particular kitty.

Taste of the Wild Cat Food

Manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, Inc., Taste of the Wild is initially released as a brand of dog food.

They later expanded the variety of their product to cater feline pets as well.

This brand is specially formulated to meet the increasing demand for grain-free pet food. However, why grain-free? Is grain not suitable food for felines?

Felines are obligate carnivores, and they don't need plant-based foods such as grains in their diet.

Grains are naturally rich in carbohydrates. Unfortunately, felines don’t require carbohydrates because they are metabolically adapted to use protein as their source of energy.

taste of the wild vs blue buffalo wilderness

Namely, obligate carnivores can survive on a meat diet alone without the need to consume grains.

Some pet food products contain grains, not for the sake of their carbohydrate value but because these serve as fillers.

Therefore, grain-free pet foods contain more proteins like meat and fish than those that include grains.

Furthermore, some kitties can develop an allergy to grains. 

Grain-free foods eliminate the possibility of causing food sensitivity in cats.

To substitute grains, other manufacturers often use potatoes, peas and apples to act as food fillers.

Taste of the Wild uses a grain-free formula containing high-quality protein like meat and fish with potatoes and peas.

True to its name, Taste of the Wild understands a cat's craving for the ‘taste of the wild.'

Using a unique formula inspired by the ancestral diets of wild felines, it is loaded with quality meats to provide feline essential nutrients.

This pet food brand is available in dry and wet varieties, which can give an excellent variation to your pet's diet.

Aside from that, each of their pet food products contains live probiotics, antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals.

These essential elements work together to ensure optimum absorption of essential nutrients and to promote proper digestion.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food

Just like the Taste of the Wild brand, Blue Buffalo was initially released as a brand of dog foods.

It all started when the Bishop family dog, Blue, caught some health problems associated with poor nutrition.

This gave Bill Bishop the initiative to create a dog food made with only the highest quality natural ingredients.

Moreover, a nutritious dog food specially formulated to meet all the requirements of a dog was born. They named the product ‘Blue Buffalo.'

Eventually, the same initiative was extended towards feline pets. The same manufacturer offered Blue Buffalo Cat Food, a variety intended to meet all the nutritional requirements of felines.

Blue Buffalo Cat Food comes in 3 varieties: dry food, wet food, and cat treat.

When it comes to options, this brand has a lot more to offer than any other brands of pet food in the market.

This brand divides the cat foods into five different product lines namely:
  • Blue for Cats
  • Freedom
  • Basics
  • Wilderness
  • Natural Veterinary Diet
taste of wild vs blue buffalo

All products under Blue for Cats line are made with the finest natural ingredients fortified with vitamins and minerals. It's a grain-free diet consisting of real meat, garden vegetables, and fruits.

However, Blue for Cats doesn’t contain poultry by-products such as chicken, duck or turkey.

The Freedom product line offers formulation intended to felines that don't do well with grain-based foods.

All products under this line are 100% grain-free. So you can be sure that it’s void of glutens that can trigger allergic reactions in cats.

Basics line is made for kitties with sensitive stomachs. Digestive problems are common among household pets, especially cats because they lack digestive enzymes to process their foods.

Blue Basics is a holistic diet using limited ingredients and grain-free formulation to minimize sensitivities to foods.

Wilderness is inspired by the diet of wild cats consisting of nothing but delicious meat.

This product line offers a meat-rich diet that contains no grains or other additives.

Natural Veterinary Diet products are exclusively available through veterinarians, and you can't merely avail it without prescription.

This Blue product line offers a therapeutic diet for feline pets with gastrointestinal problems, kidney diseases, weight issues, and food intolerance.

Each product of Blue Buffalo is as unique as your feline friend. It’s true that it’s harder to choose when there are so many options to choose from.

Consider the preferences and unique personalities of your pet to help you determine which of these products is best suited for your kitty.

Nutritional Notes

Let’s start the comparison between Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo by comparing their nutritional value.

Considering that both brands come in a wide range of varieties and product lines, presenting each of the products nutritional value would take forever.

Taste of the Wild would be more natural to present because it only has two varieties.

However, that would be unfair to the other brand if we're going to show the former of the two.

We'll be focusing solely on the most essential nutrients that are essential to felines – protein, fat, and fiber.

The tables below present the guaranteed analysis in both brands, categorized into dry and wet varieties.

Take a look at the guaranteed minimum percentages of crude protein and crude fat as well as the maximum percentages of crude fiber.

taste of wild vs blue buffalo

Dry Cat Food


Taste of the Wild

Blue Buffalo

Crude Protein

41.1%

37.4%

Crude Fat

18.9%

16.4%

Crude Fiber

3.3%

6.5%

Wet/Canned Cat Food


Taste of the Wild

Blue Buffalo

Crude Protein

44.4%

45.4%

Crude Fat

16.7%

24.7%

Crude Fiber

8.3%

8.3%

Crude Protein Comparison For Cat Food

Proteins are the easiest to digest, and they also provide essential amino acids that a cat requires.

Since felines are carnivorous animals, they require animal proteins to sustain life. Moreover, they need more protein in their diet than humans and dogs.

Hence, they need foods that are naturally rich in protein. If you’re buying cat foods, make sure to read the nutritional content and focus on its protein value.

As far as the amount of protein is concerned, you'll notice that Taste of the Wild wins the competition under the dry cat food category.

Not much of a difference though, but still worth mentioning. Under the wet food category, both brands provide nearly the same protein value.

Cat Food Comparison For Crude Fat

You’re probably asking, ‘is fat healthy?’ We often think that fat is unhealthy and it's terrible when it is added to our diet. However, the truth is, we need fat in our diet.

Fat doesn't exactly make you ‘fat.' Too much calorie intake is what makes you fat.

For felines, some amount of fat is vital to their overall well-being. Fats obtained from foods are highly digestible and are used by a feline's body as an energy source.

Apart from that, fat plays a vital role in the transportation of nutrients and other substances across cell membranes.

Plus, felines need essential fatty acids for healthy cells while producing steroid hormones necessary for bodily processes.

Now, this is where our comparison becomes a little tricky. Under dry food category, Taste of the Wild leads the way with a 2.51% differential.

However, under the wet food category, Blue Buffalo has a more significant lead of 8%.

Crude Fiber Comparison For Cat Food

If you notice in the data above, both brands don’t contain as much fiber as proteins and fats.

It should worry you at all because cats being carnivores only require low fiber in their diet. So, a low-fiber diet is not much of a problem in healthy kitties.

However, still, fiber is an essential nutrient that can aid digestion and treat gastrointestinal problems such as constipation or irregular stools.

Based on the guaranteed analysis, Blue Buffalo has a higher amount of fiber under dry food category.

Both brands provide the same amount of fiber under the wet food category.

Recipe Varieties

Flavor is also an essential factor to consider when it comes to cat food. So it's a bad thing if you're giving the same recipe to your kitty over and over again.

Try offering your furry friend different recipes from time to time. This would prevent them from getting bored of their food.

You know what happens when they get bored of their usual food, right? They tend to sneak and try human foods that are inappropriate for them.

When it comes to recipe varieties, here’s what Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo has in store for us:

taste of the wild vs blue buffalo wilderness

Dry Cat Food

Taste of the Wild

  • Rocky Mountain Feline Formula with Roasted Venison and Smoked Salmon
  • Canyon River Feline Formula with Trout and Smoked Salmon

Blue Buffalo

  • Chicken
  • Salmon
  • Duck
  • Trout
  • Rabbit
  • Red Meat
  • Chicken and Brown Rice
  • Turkey and chicken

  • Salmon and Brown Rice
  • Chicken Recipe(grain-free)
  • Fish Recipe(grain-free)
  • Fish and Potato(grain-free)
  • Turkey and Potato(grain-free)
  • Wild Salmon, Venison and Halibut
  • Turkey, Quail, and Duck
taste of wild vs blue buffalo

Wet Cat Food

Taste of the Wild

  • Rocky Mountain Feline Formula with Salmon and Roasted Venison in Gravy
  • Canyon River Feline Formula with Trout and Salmon in Gravy

Blue Buffalo

  • Chicken
  • Grain-Free Chicken
  • Chicken Entrée
  • Flaked Chicken and Trout
  • Salmon
  • Grain-Free Fish and Potato
  • Minced Chicken and Trout
  • Grain-Free Turkey
  • Turkey and Chicken Entrée
  • Grain-Free Duck and Potato
  • Flaked Chicken Entrée
  • Grain-Free Turkey and Potato
  • Beef Entrée
  • Ocean Fish and Tuna Entrée
  • Salmon Entrée
  • Grain-Free Fish
  • Flaked Fish and Shrimp Entrée
  • Flaked Tuna Entrée
  • Meaty Morsels Chicken Entrée
  • Meaty Morsels Tuna Entrée
  • Grilled Chicken Entrée
  • Grilled Salmon Entrée
  • Wild Salmon, Venison and Halibut
  • Turkey, Quail, and Duck
  • Trout Feast
  • Flaked Trout
  • Flaked Red Meat
  • Minced Chicken and Turkey
  • Chicken Morsels
  • Duck Morsels
  • Salmon Morsels

Cat Treats

Taste of the Wild

  • None

Blue Buffalo

  • Chicken
  • Shrimp
  • Chicken and Duck
  • Salmon
  • Chicken and Salmon
  • Trout
  • Chicken and Trout
  • Tuna
  • Turkey
  • Chicken and Turkey

Controversial Ingredients

We've discussed some of the beneficial ingredients used in both brands. Now it's time to look at the not-so-good parts that have stirred controversy and uncertainty among animal nutritionists.

Both brands are using the following ingredients in many of their products:

  • Canola Oil
  • Pea Protein
  • Tomato Pomace

Some veterinarians affirm that canola oil is associated with fibrotic heart lesions, lung cancer, vitamin E deficiency and growth retardation in felines.

While pea protein is rich in amino acids, some veterinarians are not amenable to the idea of adding peas in pet foods.

taste of wild vs blue buffalo

A carnivore’s digestive tract is not adapted to plant proteins. Furthermore, peas are high in phytic acid that can potentially cause obesity, diabetes and cardiovascular disease.

Tomato pomace, according to some pet owners, is a waste product leftover from processing tomatoes and has no nutritional value to felines.

By going through great processing stages, tomato pomace may contain chemical residue and preservatives that are harmful to animals.

Scientific studies have yet to confirm or deny the adverse effects of these ingredients to cats.

Aside from these controversial ingredients, Blue Buffalo still has some disputable issues to face.

Here are some of the controversial ingredients that Blue Buffalo is using in some of its products:
  • Garlic
  • Caramel
  • Caramel
  • Powdered Cellulose

Garlic is highly toxic to felines, and it could lead to fatal results if they consume it in high amounts.

While caramel is non-toxic to cats, its high sugar content can lead to weight gain, obesity, and tooth decay.

Caramel color is a water-soluble food coloring that may cause gastrointestinal upset or allergic reactions in our furry friends.

Powdered cellulose has a tremendous amount of insoluble fiber that may impede your pet’s digestive system.

Too much of it can hamper the assimilation of essential nutrients like proteins and minerals.

Product Safety: Recall History

Well, you deserve to know the times when these two brands of pet foods got recalled for specific circumstances.

On May 5, 2012, Taste of the Wild recalled thousands of its units because of positive tests for salmonella.

No further cases of the recall have been reported on this product since then.

If you think that's tragic for a pet food company, then you haven't heard about the recall history of Blue Buffalo yet.

The favorite pet food brand has recalled their products nine times for the following reasons:

  • March 18, 2017: Elevated beef thyroid hormone
  • March 3, 2017: Foil seal packaging issue
  • Feb. 14, 2017: Presence of aluminum
  • May 31, 2016: Mold
  • Nov. 25, 2015: Salmonella
  • Nov. 6, 2015: Presence of propylene glycol
  • Oct. 8, 2010: Toxic amounts of vitamin D
  • April 26, 2007: Melamine
  • April 19, 2007: Melamine

Cost Comparison

Dry Cat Food


Taste of the Wild

Blue Buffalo

Per Pound

$2.26

$3.68

Per Calorie

$0.0013

$0.0022

Wet Cat Food


Taste of the Wild

Blue Buffalo

Per Pound

$4.29

$5.47

Per Calorie

$0.0100

$0.0107

Take note that moisture has something to do with the average cost-per-lb in each brand’s products especially in wet cat foods.

In this case, you may want to consider the average cost-per-kcal metric in assessing the price value of these two brands.

taste of wild vs blue buffalo

Key Benefits

Taste of the Wild uses all natural food preservatives. It also makes use of reverse osmosis water to steam-dry all of their products to ensure that they’re free of microorganisms.

Its feline formula foods are nutritious and hearty meals ideal for cats of all life stages (kittens to senior).

Grain-free formula contains cuts of real lean meat and fish with no corn, soy, wheat, or any filler.

Instead of grains, Taste of the Wild uses fruits and vegetables to provide powerful antioxidants. Plus, it is high in omega fatty acids to maintain healthy skin and coat.

It is fortified with taurine that helps regulate digestion, heart rhythm, and vision.

Blue Buffalo, on the other hand, offers a wide range of varieties and product lines to choose from.

It takes into consideration the distinctive characteristic, preference, and medical condition of your feline pet. You have the option to go either grain-based or grain-free.

Moreover, you also have the opportunity to go for an all-meat variety. Everything you need in cat food, you name it, Blue Buffalo has it.

Similarities

So far, this article has been all about Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo comparison as we started with their fundamental differences.

However, the comparison doesn't only involve differences. We should also take their similarities into the discussion. Here are some of the things that they have in common:

Allergy Concern

Both brands are offering grain-free cat food alternatives to address those kitties with grain allergies.

Some Blue Buffalo products contain brown rice as filler. If your feline pet has some issues with gluten, you may want to avoid these particular products.

Besides, Blue Buffalo also have several grain-free products that you can avail.

Digestibility and Muscle Development

Both brands contain real meats that are wholly deboned to provide highly digestible protein that felines mostly need for survival.

Besides, the real lean meat of chicken and fish can encourage the development of long, lean muscles in felines.

Dry and Wet Food

Every pet owner has a different opinion on dry cat food vs wet cat food. The ongoing dispute on which of these food types is better has been a frequent topic among pet owners.

However, why debate when you can alternate between dry and wet cat food? Your kitty would surely appreciate some variations in its diet.

You can rest assured that both brands are using only high-quality natural ingredients.

taste of the wild vs blue buffalo wilderness

Final thoughts: Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo

Are you having a hard time choosing between the two brands: Taste of Wild vs Blue Buffalo?

Overall, both brands meet the nutritional requirements of your kitties as their products are specially formulated for the feline diet.

Based on your feline pet’s needs and conditions, you can find the right cat food that is most suitable for your kitty.

If you ask which of these two brands is better, the answer will depend on your cat’s preference and condition.

The most advantageous feature of Taste of the Wild is its use of purified water in removing harmful microorganisms from the lean meat.

Additionally, all Taste of the Wild products are grain-free which are ideal for felines with gluten allergies.

However, the number of recipe varieties is limited compared to Blue Buffalo.

With so many food options to choose from, you can pick the right food for your particular kitty.

Whether it's a young kitten or a senior cat with a certain medical condition, there’s a Blue Buffalo cat food product that is right for your pet.

Regardless of your choice, you can guarantee that any of these brands will provide all the nutrients necessary for your pet’s optimum health.

As for your furry companion, being healthy has never been this tasty. You may also to check out here for more best cat food.

References:

Leave a Comment: